Join Now!

Join our welcoming International Design Community.

Read about the many benefits of becoming and remaining a member.

Full, Associate, Departmental and Institutional Membership available.

Complete this application form to join now.

ICED 11
Papers

A Constraint-based Model of the Design Process

A Constraint-based Model of the Design Process

Year: 2011

Section: Pedagogy

Editor: Kovacevic, Ahmed, Ion, William, McMahon, Chris, Buck, Lyndon and Hogarth, Peter

Author: Scudieri, Paul; Lilly, Blaine

Series: E&PDE

Section: Pedagogy

Pages: 205-210

Abstract

The fundamental goal of the engineering and industrial design disciplines is to conceive and implement the design, fabrication, and operation of objects to meet real human needs. When the process is successful, the outcomes are embodied in something tangible—an artifact, a system, or a process—that attempts to resolve some practical problem in a non–trivial way. ‘Non–trivial’ because these designed artifacts never exist in isolation: in order for a design to be successful it must adeptly balance the many contextual factors and constraints—from performance requirements and market trends to the activity and environment of use—that are intimately tied to a specific, and unique, design problem. What this paper proposes is that the complex and dynamic context within which all specific designs emerge is actually inherent within a larger constraint environment that shapes not only the artifact itself, but also its performance, operation, and evolution. We assert as well that the processes used to generate relevant knowledge and design concepts are also affected by this constraint environment.

Here we propose a model of five distinct classes of constraints—physical, technical, market, socio-cultural, and usage—that give us a deeper understanding of this rich constraint environment and how it affects every aspect of design. By viewing all designs and their associated processes through this model we hope to provide a basis for explaining why, despite their fundamental similarity, the processes, methodologies, and outcomes associated with the engineering and industrial design disciplines are so different.

While the different design disciplines all give some consideration to the major categories of constraints, the inescapable fact that designs are inherently resource–limited means that we can never exhaustively investigate all of the constraints present in any design. Additionally, while it is tempting to view design constraints as static, they are in reality co–evolving as a result of their interaction and competition with other constraints. As a result, the constraints on which each individual design discipline or process chooses to focus, as well as the way in which they dynamically balance these multiple constraints, largely defines the design space in which they work. We see constraints as fundamental to design and believe that in order to better understand how both designers and users understand and relate to a design at all stages of its life (research, design, usage, etc.), we must first focus on being able to identify and define constraints in a more rigorous way.

Keywords: Constraints, System-design, Design-model

Download
ds conferenceE&PDE 2011: Design Education for Creativity and Business Innovation

E&PDE 2011: Design Education for Creativity and Business InnovationThe London E&PDE2011 conference is a unique opportunity for educators, practitioners and students from design-related fields to meet and exchange experiences in connecting design and business through creativity and innovation. This, the 13th International Conference on Engineering and Product Design Education, will be held at City University, London, an educational institution for business and the professions, conveniently located in Central London - one of the most vibrant business and design...

Read More

Special Interest Group (SIG)Design Education

Design EducationTo bring together academics, designers, training professionals and others throughout the world who have an interest in design education at the tertiary level....

Read More

Join Now!

Join our welcoming International Design Community.

Read about the many benefits of becoming and remaining a member.

Full, Associate, Departmental and Institutional Membership available.

Complete this application form to join now.

Download
Keywords
Design 2010